Independent inns in Castine, Maine

A seasonal Victorian on Castine's Main Street, the Pentagoet pairs period-furnished guest rooms with a pub and wine bar that doubles as the village's convivial corner. The kitchen leans upscale, and courtesy bikes wait outside for anyone inclined to explore the peninsula between courses. With a 4.7 rating across more than 200 reviews, it's the kind of small coastal inn that regulars return to for both the bed and the bar.

On Main Street in the harbor village of Castine, this long-standing Maine inn keeps a pub and restaurant downstairs, so dinner and a nightcap are a staircase away from your room. It's the kind of small-town lodging where the dining room doubles as the local gathering spot, and the village itself — walkable, coastal, quiet — is the main attraction. With 56 reviews and a 4.1 rating, it remains a modest, locally known address rather than a polished resort.